Home
Notes
Notes
Notes
Notes
Notes
Notes
Notes
Notes Index
Short Posts
P/E10
Stock Returns
Year 30 SWR
Year 15 SWR
Scenario Surfer
Strategy Tester
TIPS Table
S&P500 Dividends
S&P500 Returns
Graphs
More Graphs
Guidelines
Dividend Guidelines
Foundations
May Highlights
Lucky-7 Archives
Current Research N
Current Research O
Current Research P
Current Research Q
Current Research R
Current Re Index
Archives
Dividend Archives
Books
Contact Us
Letters Index
Letters
Letters
Letters
Letters
Letters
Letters
Letters

Simple Valuation Informed Indexing

Valuation Informed Indexing offers an advantage over buy and hold. Here is what a simple variant delivers in terms of Safe Withdrawal Rates. Typically, you make only one or two allocation shifts in a 30 year period.

The Calculator

I built a calculator to test the advantage of staying out of stocks whenever P/E10=20 and above. I kept the investor mostly out of stocks until P/E10 fell below 10. That is, I froze the allocation during long lasting (secular) Bear Markets. I did this by modifying the P/E10 data in the Deluxe V1.1A08a calculator.

My non-stock investment was 2% TIPS.

Simple Valuation Informed Indexing Results

I set the calculator to withdraw a fixed percentage of the original balance (plus adjustments to match inflation). I determined 30-year Historical Surviving Withdrawal Rates. That is, I determined the withdrawal rates at which a portfolio would have a positive balance at Year 30 but not in Year 31. I did not assume any expenses.

I have generated graphs with my results.

VIIa is what happens if the stock allocation is 100% at low P/E10 and 0% at high P/E10 and during long lasting (secular) Bear Markets.

VIIb is what happens if the stock allocation is 100% at low P/E10 and 20% at high P/E10 and during long lasting (secular) Bear Markets.

VIIc is what happens if the stock allocation is 80% at low P/E10 and 20% at high P/E10 and during long lasting (secular) Bear Markets.









Observations

VIIa and VIIb support a Safe Withdrawal Rate of 6% (plus inflation) at today’s valuations (P/E10=17 and 100E10/P=6.0%). Reducing the stock allocation to 80% during Bull Market run ups still allows you to withdraw 5.8% (plus inflation).

There is a danger with Simple Valuation Informed Indexing that you exclude yourself from the stock market for very long periods of time. This happened with the 1976 and 1977 sequences (100E10/P=9% and HSWR=6%+). That explains these two outliers. In reality, fixed income investments did considerably better than 2% TIPS during those years.

Typically, Simple Valuation Informed Indexing requires only one or two allocation shifts in a 30 year period.

Have fun.

John Walter Russell
July 26, 2009